Home > Forum > Tchaikovsky and Other Masters

Tchaikovsky and Other Masters

It has been said that Brahms was a cruel man. But many mediocre men are cruel and Brahms was a very gifted master and (as Beethoven) liked to make jokes on behalf of some of his coleagues as Bruch and Bruckner.

To Tchaikovsky, he was a very crude critic, as the russian master was of his work.

Bruckner seamt a stupid man to his contemporaries, a very naive and unsophisticated person, humble as a beggar, but a very great symphonist and religious music composer

Liszt was a "plaboy", Rossini was a very jelaous envious person, Wagner was a real scoundrel, and Bach was a saint.

Tchaikovsky was very humble, but inspired great respect and musicians were mesmerized by his personality when handling the baton.

Even to this day Tchaikovsky s critics feel embarrased when looking to his monuments or listening the greatest interpreters performing his beautiful music.

He is and always will remain one of earth's greatest creators.

Alberto Sáenz Enríquez

01/10/2011 01:51

Dear Professor Enríquez,

Tchaikovsky "is and always will remain one of earth's greatest creators." Absolutely.

The great composers seem to have been sniping at each other since the time of Mozart. As you say, Beethoven could be cruel. He told a rival composer: "I liked your opera. I'm thinking of setting it to music."

Debussy thought very highly of Grieg, but that didn't stop him from describing the Lyric Pieces as "pink bon-bons stuffed with snow."

Liszt described a shopping trip he'd taken with Chopin in the following terms: "He hoped to buy some furniture, but he couldn't find what he wanted, so of course we're in for a full fortnight of depression and 'nerves'."

Wagner of course was an absolutely horrible human being, despite also being one of earth's greatest creators. But even Wagner could be funny, as when he wrote of Brahms: "I know famous composers whom you can meet at concert masquerades, one day in the guise of a ballad singer, the next in Handel's Hallelujah wig, another time as a Jewish csardas player, and then again as genuine symphonists dressed up as number ten."

Mozart remarked about a rival composer: "His new sonata isn't totally devoid of merit, but I happen to know that he was up all night sweating over the fifths."

It amused Mahler to refer to his 8th Symphony as 'The Barnum and Bailey Show'. Having heard that Sibelius had described his own 3rd Sympony as having "nothing, absolutely nothing of the circus about it", Mahler's retort was that the symphonies of Sibelius were "antediluvian monstrosities."

Finally, Stravinsky said of Messiaen's Turangalila Symphony: "Any fool could write that, given enough music paper and an inexhaustible supply of ink!"

Each one of these brilliantly gifted individuals could have had a successful career on the stage if he'd run out of inspiration.


Michael Porter

02/10/2011 15:21

This discussion is closed and has been archived, but you are welcome to try our new forum at:

Please note that we are not responsible for the content of external web-sites

This page was last updated on 05 November 2013